Sustainable Marketing vs Traditional Marketing

Jun 6, 2024 | Green Business, Sustainable Marketing, Tips

sustainable web design

We do not inherit the earth from our ancestors, we borrow it from our children.” – Proverb


In an era of mounting environmental and social challenges, businesses must reimagine their practices through a sustainability lens. Marketing holds immense potential to drive this transformation, shaping consumer behaviour. This blog explores the powerful role of sustainable marketing in aligning profit with planetary well-being.

What is marketing?

Marketing is the practice of promoting products, services, or brands to target audiences with the goal of driving interest, engagement, and ultimately, sales. It encompasses a wide range of activities, including market research, advertising, public relations, product design and more. The origins of marketing can be traced back to ancient civilisations, however, marketing as we know it today began to take shape during the Industrial Revolution in the late 18th and early 19th centuries. 

With the rise of mass production, businesses needed to find ways to differentiate their products and reach wider audiences. In the early 20th century, marketing evolved with the emergence of new technologies like radio and television, which provided new channels for advertising. The 1950s saw the rise of consumerism and the birth of modern branding, with companies like Coca-Cola creating iconic brand images that would endure for decades.

Today, marketing has become an essential function for businesses of all sizes and industries. It plays a crucial role in shaping consumer perceptions, preferences, and behaviours, and can have a significant impact on a company’s bottom line. With the rise of digital technologies and social media, marketing has become more data-driven, personalised, and interactive than ever before.


What is the value of marketing?

The importance of marketing for business growth and success cannot be overstated. According to a study by the CMO Council, marketing is responsible for driving an average of 38% of a company’s revenue.

 A survey by Deloitte found that companies that prioritise customer experience and engagement through effective marketing see an average revenue growth rate of 17%, compared to 3% for companies that do not.

Marketing creates value for businesses and consumers by:

  1. Educating consumers about products/services that meet their needs
  2. Driving economic growth for businesses and the overall economy
  3. Sparking innovation by identifying customer needs and promoting new solutions
  4. Influencing positive behaviour change 

Effective marketing facilitates mutually beneficial exchanges between businesses and customers. It informs consumer decision-making, fuels business growth, builds brand equity, spurs innovation, and promotes societal well-being. However, marketers must ensure their practices are ethical, truthful, and aligned with the best interests of customers and broader stakeholders to create lasting value.

 

What is sustainable marketing and when did it start?

Sustainable marketing is a marketing approach that prioritises environmental, social, and economic sustainability. It involves developing and promoting products, services, and brands in a way that meets the needs of current and future generations while also driving long-term business success. Sustainable marketing recognises the interconnectedness of business, society, and the environment and seeks to create value for all stakeholders, not just shareholders.

The roots of sustainable marketing can be traced back to the environmental movement of the 1960s and 1970s, which raised awareness about the negative impact of human activities on the planet. In the 1980s, the concept of sustainable development emerged, defined by the United Nations as “development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.” This idea laid the foundation for sustainable business practices, including sustainable marketing.

However, it wasn’t until the 1990s that sustainable marketing began to gain traction as a distinct discipline. In 1992, the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (also known as the Earth Summit) took place in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. This landmark event put sustainability on the global agenda and led to the adoption of Agenda 21, a comprehensive plan for sustainable development. The Earth Summit also sparked a growing interest in sustainable business practices, including green marketing and corporate social responsibility.

In the early 2000s, sustainable marketing began to evolve from a niche concept to a mainstream business strategy. This shift was driven by several factors, including increasing consumer awareness of environmental and social issues, growing regulatory pressure, and the recognition that sustainability could be a source of competitive advantage. 

In 2002, the World Business Council for Sustainable Development published a report titled “Sustainability Through the Market,” which outlined seven keys to success for sustainable marketing. These included integrating sustainability into the core business strategy, developing sustainable products and services, and engaging stakeholders in dialogue and partnership.

Over the past two decades, it has continued to gain momentum as more companies have embraced sustainability as a core business strategy. In 2015, the United Nations adopted the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), a set of 17 global goals designed to end poverty, protect the planet, and ensure prosperity for all. The SDGs have provided a framework for businesses to align their strategies with global sustainability priorities and have further accelerated the adoption of sustainable marketing practices.

Today, sustainable marketing is no longer a fringe concept but a fundamental component of many companies’ business strategies. 

“The most important thing in communication is hearing what isn’t said,” – Peter Drucker

Marketing employs various psychological principles to influence consumer behaviour, and these tools can be harnessed in sustainable marketing to drive positive change. By understanding and applying these principles, marketers can effectively promote sustainable products, services, and behaviours, contributing to a more nature-positive and sustainable world. 

Some key psychological tools used in marketing:

  • Social Proof Theory (Cialdini, 84):
    Showcasing the growing adoption of sustainable behaviours, products, or services to encourage others to follow suit.
  • Emotional Appeals and Self-Transcendence Values (Schwartz, 92):
    Tapping into people’s desire to make a positive impact by highlighting the environmental or social benefits of sustainable choices.
  • Framing and Messaging (Tversky & Kahneman, 81):
    Emphasising the positive aspects of sustainable choices and aligning messaging with people’s values and identities.
  • Nudge Theory and Choice Architecture (Thaler & Sunstein, 08):
    Designing environments or choices to make sustainable options more visible, convenient, or appealing.
  • Narrative Transportation Theory (Green & Brock, 2000):
    Using stories to humanise environmental and social issues, create emotional connections, and showcase the impact of sustainable choices.
  • Scarcity Principle (Cialdini, 84):
    Highlighting the finite nature of natural resources or the urgency of addressing environmental and social issues.
  • Self-Identity Theory (Tajfel & Turner, 79):
    Appealing to people’s sense of self and core beliefs to encourage sustainable behaviour as an expression of their values.
  • Social Norms Theory (Cialdini et al., 90):
    Making sustainable behaviour seem normal, desirable, or expected within a given community or context.
  • Reciprocity Principle (Cialdini, 84) and Incentive Theory (Vroom, 64):
    Providing incentives or rewards for sustainable behaviour to encourage action and create positive associations.

As Peter Drucker’s quote suggests, understanding and addressing the unspoken needs and motivations of consumers is key to effective marketing, and this holds true for sustainable marketing as well. By making sustainable choices more attractive, accessible, and rewarding, marketers can help bridge the gap between people’s values and actions, contributing to a thriving and resilient future.

Why should businesses choose sustainable marketing over traditional marketing? 

In today’s increasingly environmentally and socially conscious marketplace, businesses have compelling reasons to choose sustainable marketing over traditional marketing approaches. 

Reasons to Choose Sustainable Marketing Explanation
Meet the growing consumer demand for sustainability Consumers are increasingly seeking out and willing to pay more for sustainable brands. A 2015 Nielsen study found that 66% of global consumers are willing to pay more for sustainable products, and a 2020 IBM study found that nearly 6 in 10 consumers are willing to change their shopping habits to reduce environmental impact.
Boost brand reputation and customer loyalty Sustainable marketing can enhance a company’s brand image and build trust and loyalty among customers. A 2019 Horizon Media study found that 81% of millennials expect companies to make a public commitment to sustainability. By demonstrating a genuine commitment to sustainability through their marketing efforts, businesses can differentiate themselves, improve brand reputation, and foster long-term customer loyalty.
Improve financial performance Sustainable companies tend to outperform their traditional counterparts financially. A 2015 study by Arabesque Partners found that companies with strong sustainability practices outperformed the market by 21%. This could be due to various factors, such as increased consumer demand, improved risk management, and better talent attraction and retention.
Drive innovation and competitive advantage Sustainable marketing can drive innovation by pushing companies to develop more environmentally and socially responsible products, services, and business models. A Harvard Business Review article from 2016 argues that sustainable initiatives can provide a competitive edge by creating new market opportunities, reducing costs, and mitigating risks.
Mitigate risks and future-proof the business Sustainable marketing can help businesses mitigate various risks, such as reputational damage, supply chain disruptions, and regulatory penalties. As governments worldwide implement stricter sustainability regulations and consumers become more critical of unsustainable practices, companies that proactively embrace sustainable marketing will be better positioned to navigate these challenges and ensure long-term viability.

 

Why is sustainable marketing vital to achieving the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals? 

Sustainable marketing is crucial for reaching the UN SDGs as it can raise awareness about sustainability challenges, drive demand for products and services that address these challenges, and encourage more sustainable consumption and production patterns. 

By promoting sustainable lifestyles and responsible business practises, sustainable marketing can contribute to multiple SDGs, including responsible consumption and production (SDG12), climate action (SDG13), and partnerships for the goals (SDG17).


What is a digital carbon footprint? Why is it bad? And how can sustainable marketing help minimise it? 

A digital carbon footprint is the amount of carbon dioxide (CO2) and other greenhouse gases emitted by the use of digital devices, the internet, and the supporting infrastructure. This includes emissions from the manufacture, use, and disposal of devices like smartphones, computers, and servers, as well as the energy consumed by data centres and networks that power the internet. The digital carbon footprint is a growing concern because of the increasing reliance on digital technologies in our daily lives and the rapid growth of the internet. 

Some key facts and figures highlight the scale of the problem:

  • The energy consumption of the global IT sector is estimated to account for 2-3% of global greenhouse gas emissions, comparable to the aviation industry (Lean ICT Report, 2019).
  • Data centres alone are expected to consume around 3-5% of global electricity by 2025 (Anders Andrae, Total Consumer Power Consumption Forecast, 2017).
  • The carbon footprint of the internet is expected to double by 2025, reaching 1.25 gigatons of CO2 equivalent per year (The Shift Project, 2019).

The growing digital carbon footprint is problematic because it contributes to climate change, which has far-reaching consequences for the environment, human health, and the economy. Greenhouse gas emissions trap heat in the atmosphere, leading to rising temperatures, sea levels, and more frequent and intense extreme weather events. This, in turn, can lead to ecosystem damage, food and water insecurity, displacement of communities, and significant economic losses.

Sustainable marketing can play a crucial role in minimising our digital carbon footprint helping us on the journey towards a net zero future and paving the way for a greener, more just, and equitable future for generations to come.

  • Promoting energy-efficient devices and data centres: Creating demand for energy-efficient smartphones, computers with low power consumption, and data centres powered by renewable energy sources. By making these greener options more appealing, marketers can incentivise companies to invest in environmentally-friendly technologies.

  • Encouraging sustainable digital habits: Educating consumers about the environmental impact of their digital activities and promoting more eco-conscious habits. This could include encouraging people to delete unnecessary emails and files, reduce video streaming quality, and turn off devices when not in use. By raising awareness and providing practical tips, marketers can empower individuals to reduce their personal digital footprint.

  • Supporting green digital initiatives: Amplifying and supporting initiatives aimed at reducing the digital sector’s environmental impact. This could include promoting green web hosting providers, advocating for renewable energy use in the IT sector, and supporting research and development of more energy-efficient technologies. By aligning with and promoting these initiatives, marketers can help drive systemic change toward a more sustainable digital future.

  • Leading by example: Marketing agencies can lead by example by adopting eco-friendly digital practices within their own operations. This could include using energy-efficient devices, choosing green web hosting, optimising websites for lower energy consumption, and offsetting their digital carbon footprint. By demonstrating their commitment to digital sustainability, marketers can inspire others to follow suit.

  • Driving innovation in eco-friendly digital solutions: Creating demand for more sustainable digital products and services. This could include promoting the development of circular economy models for electronic devices, supporting the growth of the green software engineering field, and other technologies to optimise energy efficiency. By signalling market demand for these sustainable innovations, marketers can help accelerate their adoption and scalability.

  • Driving the adoption of clean energy and energy-efficient technologies: These marketing approaches can accelerate the adoption of clean energy sources like solar, wind, and geothermal power by promoting their benefits and making them more attractive to consumers. Marketers can also promote energy-efficient technologies, such as LED lighting, smart thermostats, and electric vehicles, which can significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions. By creating demand for these sustainable solutions, marketers can help drive down costs and make them more accessible to a wider range of consumers.

  • Promoting circular economy principles: These strategies can promote the principles of the circular economy, which aims to reduce waste, keep materials in use for as long as possible, and regenerate natural systems. Marketers can encourage consumers to choose products designed for durability, repairability, and recyclability, as well as promote product-as-a-service models, which prioritise access over ownership. By shifting consumer preferences towards more circular products and services, marketers can help reduce the extraction of virgin resources and minimise waste, contributing to a more sustainable future.|

  • Encouraging sustainable consumption and behaviour change: Marketers can educate consumers about the environmental and social impact of their choices and provide information and tools to help them make more sustainable decisions. This could include promoting plant-based diets, encouraging the use of public transport or active mobility, and supporting the sharing economy. By making sustainable living more desirable, accessible, and convenient, marketers can help drive widespread behaviour change, which is essential for reaching net zero targets.

  • Advocating for sustainable policies and regulations: These marketing efforts can help build public support for sustainable policies and regulations, such as carbon pricing, renewable energy mandates, and eco-labelling schemes. Marketers can use their communication skills to raise awareness about the importance of these policies and mobilise consumers to advocate for change. They can also work with policymakers to develop and promote policies that create an enabling environment for sustainable products and services. By advocating for sustainable policies and regulations, marketers can help create the necessary framework for a more sustainable future.

  • Promoting social equity and inclusion: These marketing strategies can help promote social equity and inclusion by highlighting the social and economic benefits of a just transition to a low-carbon economy. Marketers can promote products and services that create jobs and opportunities for disadvantaged communities, such as community-owned renewable energy projects or fair trade products. They can also use their platforms to raise awareness about social justice issues and advocate for policies that promote equity and inclusion. By promoting social equity and inclusion, marketers can help ensure that all share the benefits of a sustainable future.

In conclusion, these marketing efforts are not just a trend or a niche approach; they are necessary for businesses and societies to thrive in mounting environmental and social challenges. By leveraging the power of marketing, we can drive the adoption of clean technologies, encourage responsible consumption, and foster a circular economy.

Sustainable marketing is a catalyst for innovation, a driver of positive behaviour change, and a crucial tool in achieving the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals. As we navigate the complexities of the 21st century, embracing these approaches is not just an ethical choice but a strategic imperative for businesses seeking long-term success and for humanity seeking a prosperous and regenerative future on our planet.

 

portrait of Marta Gintowt

Written by
Pollyanna Durbin

SHARE

For more information on how to make your digital marketing strategy more sustainable, get in touch with a member of the team at growfish.co

Related Posts

Examples of Sustainable Marketing 

Examples of Sustainable Marketing 

In recent years, sustainability has become a key priority for consumers and businesses alike. As more people recognise the urgent need to address climate change and protect our planet’s resources, brands are finding innovative ways to incorporate sustainability into...